By Melissa
from Savannah, GA on 11/12/2008
Waist:
Feels true to size
Length:
Feels true to length
Pros:
Attractive Design, Comfortable, Nice Fabric
Describe Yourself:
Classic Dresser
Comfort vs Style:
Style Driven
Bottom Line:
Yes, I would recommend this to a friend
Nice lined skirt, but it wrinkles easily.
By Practical Peg from Northern Michigan on 11/11/2008
Waist:
Feels true to size
Length:
Feels true to length
Pros:
Attractive Design, Comfortable, Flattering, High Quality, Nice Fabric, Versatile, Wrinkle Resistant
Best Uses:
Casual Wear, Going Out, Special Occasions, Wear To Work
Describe Yourself:
Classic Dresser
Comfort vs Style:
Comfort Driven
This skirt has a nicer fit than even the photos of it in the catalog. It is not as heavy a wool as I was expecting but it is sleek and classy and comfortable. Very versatile
By bargain shopper from Brentwood, TN on 11/6/2008
Waist:
Feels true to size
Length:
Feels true to length
Pros:
Comfortable, Flattering, Perfect weight for fall, Wrinkle Resistant
Best Uses:
Casual Wear, Going Out, Wear To Work
Describe Yourself:
Casual Dresser
Comfort vs Style:
Comfort Driven
Bottom Line:
Yes, I would recommend this to a friend
I loved the weight of this skirt. I had summer and then winter weight clothes and needed something for moderate weather. I can wear this skirt with a sweater or a knit top and it still looks good.
By Nana from Pennsylvania on 11/6/2008
Waist:
Feels true to size
Length:
Feels true to length
Pros:
Attractive Design, Comfortable, Flattering, High Quality, Nice Fabric, Versatile, Wrinkle Resistant
Best Uses:
Casual Wear, Going Out, Special Occasions, Wear To Work
Describe Yourself:
Trendy/Stylish Dresser
Comfort vs Style:
Comfort Driven
Bottom Line:
Yes, I would recommend this to a friend
Haven't had a chance to wear the skirt yet, but have tried it on and love it.
excellent except tiny waist
By Working mom from Seattle on 11/5/2008
Length:
Feels true to length
Pros:
Attractive Design, Comfortable, Flattering, High Quality, Nice Fabric, Versatile, Wrinkle Resistant
Best Uses:
Going Out, Wear To Work
Describe Yourself:
Trendy/Stylish Dresser
Comfort vs Style:
Style Driven
Bottom Line:
Yes, I would recommend this to a friend
Excellent fit and length for work but warning, waist runs very small, had to reorder a size up.
Also wish the wool waistband were lined like the rest of the skirt
By Pinkie from Chicago on 11/5/2008
Length:
Feels true to length
Pros:
Attractive Design, Versatile
Cons:
Poor Fit, Wrinkles Easily
Describe Yourself:
Classic Dresser
Bottom Line:
No, I would not recommend this to a friend
This skirt must styled be along "contemporary" fit guidelines, or to flatter the vanity of women who really wear a larger size. Age and experience support my remembrance of how size 2 should fit, and this skirt does not!
By Bigred from FranklinVA on 11/4/2008
Waist:
Feels true to size
Length:
Feels true to length
Pros:
Attractive Design, Flattering, Nice Fabric
Best Uses:
Church, Wear To Work
Describe Yourself:
Classic Dresser
Comfort vs Style:
Comfort Driven
Bottom Line:
Yes, I would recommend this to a friend
I ordered 2 in the 4p and felt that they were a little big in the waist..So I ordered the 2p and it fit in the waist while standing, just not sure how it will be once I sit most of the day. Not the skirt, but Me. Nice looking for work and church
By ka6t from Watkins Glen NY on 10/31/2008
Waist:
Feels true to size
Length:
Feels true to length
Pros:
Attractive Design, Comfortable, Flattering
Describe Yourself:
Classic Dresser
Comfort vs Style:
Style Driven
For the price and the fact that this skirt is supposed to be wool, it is very light weight. Not what I expected.
By Traci from Grand Prairie, TX on 10/31/2008
Waist:
Feels true to size
Length:
Feels true to length
Pros:
Attractive Design, Comfortable, Flattering, Versatile
Describe Yourself:
Classic Dresser
Comfort vs Style:
Comfort Driven
Bottom Line:
Yes, I would recommend this to a friend
This skirt is really cute and flattering when worn. If fit comfortably around my waist and was not too tight. The length was perfect and looked trendy with a boot. The only down side is it didn't really feel like wool to me...it's a little more thin than I expected, but does have an additional lining to protect from itching and add a little extra warmth.
well made skirt but a litte small
By lily from Maryland on 10/29/2008
Length:
Feels true to length
Pros:
Attractive Design, High Quality, Nice Fabric, Versatile
Best Uses:
Going Out, Wear To Work
Describe Yourself:
Classic Dresser
Comfort vs Style:
Style Driven
Love the skirt, but even though I bought a larger size of the two sizes I normally wear (6 or 8), I have to return it. It is lined, nicely made and I really like the plaid patten.
Lovely tartan plaid school girl skirt
By Lois the Legal Assistant from North Palm Beach, FL on 10/24/2008
Waist:
Feels true to size
Length:
Feels true to length
Pros:
Attractive Design, Comfortable, Flattering, High Quality, Nice Fabric, Versatile, Wrinkle Resistant
Describe Yourself:
Classic Dresser
Comfort vs Style:
Style Driven
Bottom Line:
Yes, I would recommend this to a friend
I wear this with a navy, classic blazer with brass buttons and a hot pink shell. Looks smashing!
By visiongirl from new mexico on 10/22/2008
Waist:
Feels true to size
Length:
Feels true to length
Pros:
Attractive Design, Comfortable, Flattering, High Quality, Nice Fabric, Versatile, Wrinkle Resistant
Describe Yourself:
Classic Dresser
Comfort vs Style:
Comfort Driven
Bottom Line:
Yes, I would recommend this to a friend
Great skirts, I ordered two and love them both. Look really good with opaque tights and boots. Will wear them to work.
By rits from CR, Iowa on 10/21/2008
Length:
Feels true to length
Pros:
Attractive Design, Flattering, Nice Fabric
Best Uses:
Casual Wear, Going Out, Wear To Work
Describe Yourself:
Trendy/Stylish Dresser
Comfort vs Style:
Style Driven
Bottom Line:
Yes, I would recommend this to a friend
Lovely skirt!
pictures don't match swatches
By jewely from Wayne, MI on 10/20/2008
Bottom Line:
Yes, I would recommend this to a friend
the pictures do not match the swatches.
where's the b&w houndstooth?
needs more solid colors.
Wool Skirt 12P. Reorder 14P to get fit!
By She'sOntheLake from North Carolina on 10/15/2008
Length:
Feels true to length
Pros:
Attractive Design, Flattering, True camel color
Describe Yourself:
Classic Dresser
Comfort vs Style:
Comfort Driven
Bottom Line:
No, I would not recommend this to a friend
At 5'2 and 125 lbs I normally wear an 8P or 10P. Your 12P was way too small. With the customer online comments I gambled and ordered the camel wool skirt 14P~two sizes larger than normal and it does fit. [...]
By Kyung from Bloomfield Hills, Michigan on 10/15/2008
Waist:
Feels true to size
Length:
Feels true to length
Pros:
Comfortable, Flattering, Versatile
Cons:
Color Not As Expected, Low Quality
Best Uses:
Casual Wear, Wear To Work
Describe Yourself:
Classic Dresser
Bottom Line:
Yes, I would recommend this to a friend
Nice basic skirt, material is a bit thin, worth the sale price though. Would not buy at full price. Would like to buy this in more solid colors and different prints (all the plaids are the 'same' plaid print)
By Maui Girl from Aurora, CO on 10/14/2008
Waist:
Feels true to size
Length:
Feels true to length
Pros:
Attractive Design, Comfortable, Durable, Flattering, High Quality, Wrinkle Resistant
Describe Yourself:
Classic Dresser
Bottom Line:
Yes, I would recommend this to a friend
It is a very beautiful plaid and it fits very well. Great piece for work.
By eah from NJ on 10/10/2008
Waist:
Feels true to size
Length:
Feels true to length
Pros:
Attractive Design, Comfortable, Flattering
Describe Yourself:
Trendy/Stylish Dresser
Comfort vs Style:
Style Driven
Bottom Line:
Yes, I would recommend this to a friend
I got two of these. They rounded out my fall/winter wardrobe. I know they'll be versatile. Haven't worn them yet, but I like the weight. Not too heavy.
By Elfie from Wichita, KS on 10/9/2008
Waist:
Feels true to size
Length:
Feels true to length
Pros:
Attractive Design, Comfortable, Nice Fabric
Describe Yourself:
Classic Dresser
Comfort vs Style:
Comfort Driven
Bottom Line:
Yes, I would recommend this to a friend
I loved that the lining was tacked to the skirt. A small detail but many times the lining hangs below the skirt. The bandless waistband is very flattering. This was just the right size and felt really good all day long.
By mattjomar from Gibbstown, Nj on 10/7/2008
Waist:
Feels true to size
Length:
Feels true to length
Pros:
Attractive Design, Comfortable, Flattering, Nice Fabric, Wrinkle Resistant
Best Uses:
Special Occasions, Wear To Work
Describe Yourself:
Classic Dresser
Comfort vs Style:
Comfort Driven
Bottom Line:
Yes, I would recommend this to a friend
great look, feel and fit. It's a classic.
By TraciofNH from New Hampshire on 10/7/2008
Waist:
Feels true to size
Length:
Feels true to length
Pros:
Attractive Design, Comfortable, Flattering, Nice Fabric
Best Uses:
Casual Wear, Going Out, Special Occasions, Wear To Work
Describe Yourself:
Classic Dresser
Comfort vs Style:
Comfort Driven
Bottom Line:
Yes, I would recommend this to a friend
I like how versatile this skirt is. I can wear it dressy with a blouse and blazer, or I prefer to wear it with a turtleneck and tall boots.
It goes from day to evening quite easily. It fits well, and washes up nicely.
I am petite, so it did need to be hemmed.
By Retired skier from Estes Park on 10/1/2008
Waist:
Feels true to size
Length:
Feels true to length
Pros:
Comfortable, Flattering, Nice Fabric, Versatile, Wrinkle Resistant
Best Uses:
Casual Wear, I wear to church, Wear To Work
Describe Yourself:
Classic Dresser
Comfort vs Style:
Comfort Driven
Bottom Line:
Yes, I would recommend this to a friend
I was looking for skirt to wear for church and slip into when we go out to eat dinner.
Good value, but runs small
By Lisa from Silver Spring, Maryland on 9/30/2008
Waist:
Feels true to size
Length:
Feels true to length
Pros:
Attractive Design, Versatile, Wrinkle Resistant
Describe Yourself:
Classic Dresser
Comfort vs Style:
Comfort Driven
Bottom Line:
Yes, I would recommend this to a friend
Good value, but runs a little small. Nice, thin, "three season" weight.
By n/a from Pittsburgh, Pa. on 9/30/2008
Waist:
Feels true to size
Length:
Feels true to length
Pros:
Attractive Design, Comfortable
Best Uses:
Casual Wear, Wear To Work
Describe Yourself:
Casual Dresser
Comfort vs Style:
Comfort Driven
Bottom Line:
Yes, I would recommend this to a friend
I like the skirt-would really like it a lot better if the sweater that goes with it was not on back-order for so long
By Marybeth from Cincinnati on 9/30/2008
Waist:
Feels true to size
Length:
Feels true to length
Pros:
Attractive Design, Comfortable
Best Uses:
Casual Wear, Going Out, Wear To Work
Describe Yourself:
Classic Dresser
Comfort vs Style:
Comfort Driven
Bottom Line:
Yes, I would recommend this to a friend
very comfortable skirt that is not too dressy
I would buy this again in a different co
By mary b from Lyndhurst, NJ on 9/30/2008
Waist:
Feels true to size
Length:
Feels true to length
Cons:
Color Not As Expected
Describe Yourself:
Classic Dresser
Comfort vs Style:
Comfort Driven
Bottom Line:
Yes, I would recommend this to a friend
My only comment is the fact that the color stated is not the color of the skirt. It states brown when to me, it is a black with red stripes.
By Roma from Houston on 9/27/2008
Waist:
Feels true to size
Length:
Feels true to length
Pros:
Attractive Design, Comfortable, Flattering, Versatile
Best Uses:
Going Out, Special Occasions, Wear To Work
Describe Yourself:
Classic Dresser
Comfort vs Style:
Comfort Driven
Bottom Line:
Yes, I would recommend this to a friend
Really like this skirt. Very versatile.
By Happy in Bakersfield from Bakersfield, CA. on 9/27/2008
Waist:
Feels true to size
Length:
Feels true to length
Pros:
Attractive Design, Comfortable, Durable, Flattering, High Quality
Describe Yourself:
Trendy/Stylish Dresser
Comfort vs Style:
Comfort Driven
Bottom Line:
Yes, I would recommend this to a friend
I have several of these skirts, Love them!
By rs/sahm from PA on 9/25/2008
Waist:
Feels true to size
Length:
Feels true to length
Pros:
Attractive Design, Classic colors, Versatile
Cons:
Low Quality, Wool is flimsy thin
Best Uses:
Church, Special Occasions, Wear To Work
Describe Yourself:
Casual Dresser
Comfort vs Style:
Comfort Driven
Bottom Line:
Yes, I would recommend this to a friend
pretty fabric but the wool is thin and flimsy... I felt as though it didn't live up to the price. I'd recommend it on sale!
order 2 one too small, the other ok
By gemy from MA on 9/19/2008
Waist:
Feels true to size
Length:
Feels true to length
Pros:
Attractive Design, Comfortable, Flattering
Best Uses:
Going Out, Wear To Work
Describe Yourself:
Classic Dresser
Comfort vs Style:
Comfort Driven
Bottom Line:
Yes, I would recommend this to a friend
Wish the other skirt, my favorite had been the oorrect size
By gramma from Tennessee on 9/9/2008
Length:
Feels true to length
Cons:
Poor Fit, Sizing appears incorrect
Describe Yourself:
Classic Dresser
Bottom Line:
No, I would not recommend this to a friend
I bought two of these skirts. I have always worn a 10P in Chadwick's clothes and the solid color 10P fit me perfectly. The plaid skirt was a whole other story. It was at least TWO INCHES larger than the solid skirt. It felt more like a 12 or 14 than a 10. This is the opposite problem from what happened with the blazers. The solid 10P did fit, but the plaid blazer was at least 2 sizes too SMALL!! Same brand, ordered at the same time. It's getting so that I can't trust Chadwick sizes any more and I HATE spending money on tailoring or postage to send ill-fitting clothes back. I'm real close to asking to be removed from the catalog list.
By DRH from Yucca Valley, CA on 9/9/2008
Waist:
Feels true to size
Describe Yourself:
Classic Dresser
Comfort vs Style:
Comfort Driven
Bottom Line:
No, I would not recommend this to a friend
The skirt was attractive but the was material "itchy" around the waist due to the no-waist band styling. Additionally, I thought for a petite, it was to long. I returned it due to it's uncomfortable waist.
By teresa from [@] Frankfort, In. on 9/4/2008
Waist:
Feels true to size
Length:
Feels true to length
Pros:
Attractive Design, Comfortable
Best Uses:
Business meeting, Church
Describe Yourself:
Bargain Shopper, Career, Casual
Bottom Line:
Yes, I would recommend this to a friend
i like the colors, can wait for the sweater to go with it.
Runs smal, but is fantastic!
By lojo from edmond, ok on 8/24/2008
Length:
Feels true to length
Pros:
Attractive Design, High Quality
Best Uses:
Cocktail Party, On a Date, Special Occasions, To School, To Work
Describe Yourself:
Bargain Shopper, Career, Casual, Classic
Bottom Line:
Yes, I would recommend this to a friend
I have another skirt that I bought last season, same size but Chadwick's, not JG Hook. They are entirely different. This skirt is very cute, but runs about one size small.
J.G. HOOK WOOL PENCIL SKIRT
By N/A from LYNDHURST, NJ on 8/15/2008
Waist:
Feels true to size
Length:
Feels true to length
Pros:
Attractive Design, Comfortable, Durable, Flattering, Versatile, Wrinkle Resistant
Describe Yourself:
Bargain Shopper, Career, Classic, Eclectic
Bottom Line:
Yes, I would recommend this to a friend
J.G. HOOK SKIRTS FIT ME PERFECTLY. [...]
By Clothes Addict from Chambersburg, PA on 8/14/2008
Waist:
Feels true to size
Length:
Feels true to length
Pros:
Comfortable, Flattering, Versatile
Best Uses:
Casual Work Days, To Work
Describe Yourself:
Bargain Shopper, Career, Casual
Bottom Line:
Yes, I would recommend this to a friend
I bought this skirt in several colors. It's great for the office with a button down and jacket or dressed down with a sweater and flats. And it fits perfectly! You can't go wrong!
Perfect for Work or Casual Dates
By NurseChris from Somerset, NJ on 7/2/2008
Waist:
Feels true to size
Pros:
Attractive Design, Comfortable, Flattering, Wrinkle Resistant
Best Uses:
Comfort-Oriented, On a Date, To School, To Work
Describe Yourself:
Bargain Shopper, Career, Casual
Bottom Line:
Yes, I would recommend this to a friend
Love the cut of the skirt. Love the colors. Even though the plaids are large, it does not add weight to your appearance. Pair the skirt with a short sleeved turtleneck and matching tights and your ready to go. A nice alternative to wearing jeans on a date.
By sarah jane from columbia, sc on 6/19/2008
Waist:
Feels true to size
Length:
Feels true to length
Pros:
Attractive Design, Comfortable, Flattering
Describe Yourself:
Bargain Shopper, Career, Classic
Bottom Line:
Yes, I would recommend this to a friend
Since I am only about 5 feet tall, and fairly slim, I have a hard time finding skirts appropriate for office attire that actually fit. This skirt fit well in the waist and hips, and the length was great as well. Overall, very pleased.
By kayaking karen from Kingston,NY on 5/25/2008
Waist:
Feels true to size
Length:
Feels true to length
Pros:
Attractive Design, Comfortable, Durable, Flattering, High Quality, Versatile, Wrinkle Resistant
Describe Yourself:
Bargain Shopper, Career, Casual, Classic
Bottom Line:
Yes, I would recommend this to a friend
This is a classic and the fawn color makes it very versatile!
One of my favorite skirts
By elsuje from North Andover, MA on 4/9/2008
Waist:
Feels true to size
Length:
Feels true to length
Pros:
Attractive Design, Comfortable, Durable, Flattering, High Quality, Versatile
Describe Yourself:
Bargain Shopper, Casual, Classic
Bottom Line:
Yes, I would recommend this to a friend
Good for work - not too casual, not too dressy
[1 of 1 customers found this review helpful]
By emw from AL on 3/28/2008
Length:
Feels true to length
Pros:
High Quality, Versatile
Describe Yourself:
Bargain Shopper
Bottom Line:
Yes, I would recommend this to a friend
the waist is half size too small but the hip is very generous. if you want a slim look then do not choose this one.
Great everyday or night skirt
By The teacher from Sharon, Ma on 3/28/2008
Waist:
Feels true to size
Length:
Feels true to length
Pros:
Attractive Design, Comfortable, Flattering, High Quality, Versatile, Wish it came in more colo
Best Uses:
Cocktail Party, Comfort-Oriented, On a Date, To School, To Work
Describe Yourself:
Bargain Shopper, Career, Casual, Classic, Sexy
Bottom Line:
Yes, I would recommend this to a friend
I wear the different color skirts everyday to teach in.
By Sandy from New York, NY on 3/26/2008
Waist:
Feels true to size
Length:
Feels true to length
Pros:
Attractive Design, Comfortable, Flattering, Wrinkle Resistant
Best Uses:
Casual Work Days, On a Date, Special Occasions, To Work
Describe Yourself:
Bargain Shopper, Career, Casual, Trendy
Bottom Line:
Yes, I would recommend this to a friend
The skirt is very flattering, versatile and elegant.
By Marg from Lafayette, IN on 3/20/2008
Waist:
Feels true to size
Length:
Feels true to length
Pros:
Attractive Design, Comfortable, Durable, Flattering, High Quality, Wrinkle Resistant
Best Uses:
Comfort-Oriented, Special Occasions, To Work
Describe Yourself:
Career, Casual, Classic, Trendy
Bottom Line:
Yes, I would recommend this to a friend
I love this skirt. I have also purchased one more just a different color.
ABSOLUTELY Loved this skirt!
By pampoochie from Somerset, MA on 3/14/2008
Waist:
Feels true to size
Length:
Feels true to length
Pros:
Comfortable, Flattering, High Quality
Best Uses:
Casual Work Days, To School, To Work
Describe Yourself:
Bargain Shopper, Career, Classic, Sexy
Bottom Line:
Yes, I would recommend this to a friend
Would have loved to buy this skirt in several solid colors - but only two solids and plaid...
[1 of 1 customers found this review helpful]
great blazer for mixing into wardrobe
By shoe crazy from Augusta, ME on 3/5/2008
Sizing:
Feels true to size
Waist:
Feels true to size
Length:
Feels true to length
Pros:
Attractive Design, Flattering, Versatile
Cons:
Fair quality fair price
Best Uses:
On The Weekend, To Work
Describe Yourself:
Classic, Conservative
Bottom Line:
Yes, I would recommend this to a friend
Works with slacks & skirts for work and jeans for the weekend.
By Mugdhali from Charlotte. NC on 3/4/2008
Sizing:
Feels true to size
Waist:
Feels true to size
Length:
Feels true to length
Pros:
Attractive Design, Flattering
Best Uses:
Casual Work Days, On The Weekend, To Work
Describe Yourself:
Career, Conservative
Bottom Line:
Yes, I would recommend this to a friend
loved the fitting
By Sunshine from NJ on 3/2/2008
Sizing:
Feels full size too small
Length:
Feels true to length
Pros:
Attractive Design, Comfortable, Flattering
Cons:
Low Quality, Poor Fit, Thin Material
Best Uses:
Casual Work Days, On a Date, To School, To Work
Describe Yourself:
Bargain Shopper, Career, Casual
Bottom Line:
No, I would not recommend this to a friend
Returned the skirt and would not recommend it.
By Working Grandmother from Tennessee on 2/29/2008
Sizing:
Feels true to size
Waist:
Feels true to size
Length:
Feels true to length
Describe Yourself:
Classic
Bottom Line:
No, I would not recommend this to a friend
It seems like the quality of the clothes from Chadwick's is going down hill. More and more I find myself sending things back because of poor quality. This "100% Wool" skirt is so thin it feels more like cotton. I'll keep it because I need a black skirt, but I also purchased a suit at the same time that[...]poor quality.
By Carrie from Dayton, OH on 2/22/2008
Describe Yourself:
High-end shopper, Stylish
Sizing:
Feels true to size
Waist:
Feels true to size
Length:
Feels true to length
Pros:
Attractive Design, Comfortable, Durable, Versatile, Wrinkle Resistant
Bottom Line:
Yes, I would recommend this to a friend
Can dress it up or down.
[1 of 1 customers found this review helpful]
really nice - would buy again
By BB from CT on 2/20/2008
Describe Yourself:
Stylish
Sizing:
Feels true to size
Waist:
Feels true to size
Length:
Feels true to length
Pros:
Attractive Design, Comfortable, Durable, Nice fabric
Cons:
A little too high waisted
Bottom Line:
Yes, I would recommend this to a friend
I really like the fabric. It's wool but not a thick, heavy wool. Very comfortable and classic looking.
By Dianne from Portage PA on 2/16/2008
Describe Yourself:
Comfort-oriented
Sizing:
Feels true to size
Best Uses:
Daytime, Office
Length:
Feels true to length
Pros:
Comfortable, Wrinkle Resistant
Bottom Line:
Yes, I would recommend this to a friend
I purchased this skirt to wear at the office after I saw it on one of the other employees (she has a different color) It is very comfortable and I love the fact that it does not wrinkle. Also, being I am only 5'1", the length is great.
By Patty from Framingham, MA on 2/14/2008
Describe Yourself:
Comfort-oriented, Stylish
Sizing:
Feels true to size
Waist:
Feels true to size
Length:
Feels true to length
Pros:
Attractive Design, Comfortable, Durable, Versatile, Wrinkle Resistant
Bottom Line:
Yes, I would recommend this to a friend
Was very pleased with the quality and fit.
By fran from ct on 2/13/2008
Describe Yourself:
Stylish
Sizing:
Feels true to size
Print This Page